| Platinum | Cicciotti's Trattoria Italiana & Seafood |
| Gold | Jay's Gourmet Pizza & Seafood |
| Silver | Spirito's Italian Diner |
| Bronze | Vigilucci's Cucina |
| Top Pick | Gregorio's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Paradise Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pizza Port |
| Top Pick | That Pizza Place |
| Top Pick | Via Vai |