| Nominate Nominated! | Blade 1936 |
| Nominate Nominated! | Cicciotti's Trattoria Italiana & Seafood |
| Nominate Nominated! | Cusimano's Pizzeria |
| Nominate Nominated! | Dominic's Italian Restaurant |
| Nominate Nominated! | Gianni's Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Leucadia Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Paradise Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Pizza Port |
| Nominate Nominated! | Prager Brothers Artisan Breads |
| Nominate Nominated! | Roma's Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Round Table |
| Nominate Nominated! | Vigilucci's Seafood and Steakhouse |